Search
Blue-gray glazed front door and white-trimmed window in weathered cedar shingles above a worn gray wooden porch.

Wimpy's Roadhouse in Hyannis: Dinner, Menu and the Move

"It will be Wimpy's Roadhouse, although we can't officially call it that until the state ABCC approves it," co-owner Adam Hostetter told the Cape Cod Times in early October. ABCC is the Alcoholic Beverages Control Commission.

So if you drive to 488 South St. this month expecting a Wimpy's sign, you'll find the Roadhouse. Wimpy's staff, chowder and baked scrod got to Hyannis first, and the name comes after the paperwork. For now the place is a dinner restaurant running under the Roadhouse name, with the Wimpy's year-round team working inside.

Eighty-Eight Summers at 752 Main Street

Raymond and Winnie Hostetter opened Wimpy's at 752 Main St. in Osterville in 1938, according to the Cape Cod Times. Their grandson Adam Hostetter now co-owns the business.

It looked like this year would be the end of that run. Then came a surprise lease extension. "Our lease has been extended until Labor Day of 2026! We are very excited to remain in Osterville for our 88th summer season!" Hostetter wrote on Wimpy's Facebook page, as the Cape Cod Times reported in March.

The extra summer bought time, but the lease was still not renewed. The fall went like this:

Date What happened
March 16, 2026 Lease extension through Labor Day announced
Sept. 24, 2026 Move to Hyannis announced, with Oct. 10 as the last day in Osterville
Sept. 26, 2026 Hostetter and Adrian Pryshlak buy The Roadhouse at 488 South St.
Oct. 6, 2026 One-day price rollback in Osterville
Oct. 10, 2026 Last day on Main Street in Osterville
Oct. 19, 2026 Wimpy's staff begin working at the Roadhouse

On the rollback day, Wimpy's charged its earliest known prices. "On the earliest menu we could find, hamburgers are 40 cents, cheeseburgers 50 cents and hot dogs 30 cents," Hostetter told the Cape Cod Times.

The owners wanted a short gap. "The goal is to have it closed for not quite a week. We plan on doing it very quickly," Hostetter said of the move in the Sept. 24 report. It ended up taking nine days from the last Osterville service to the first night on South Street.

What Opened on Oct. 19 Was the Team

The restaurant now bills itself as "Roadhouse, joined by Wimpy's staff," and it says the collaboration began October 19, 2026.

The site also explains why the move happened in this order. "Keeping our year-round team employed was a priority before purchasing Roadhouse," it reads. "While we await the license transfer, Roadhouse is providing a home for that team to continue doing what they love: welcoming guests and bringing people together around the table."

That timing matters on the Cape. Wimpy's left Osterville in mid-October, after the busy season, and its year-round staff moved straight into an operating restaurant a few miles away. The kitchen kept running, the servers kept working, and the name on the building can catch up once the state finishes the license transfer.

Where the Two Menus Meet

The Roadhouse describes the dinner menu as "Roadhouse dishes and classic Wimpy's favorites." It covers seafood, steaks, pasta and a section of handhelds.

These prices come from the dinner menu posted on the Roadhouse website this fall:

Dish Price What comes with it
Quahog Chowder $8 cup / $12 bowl Cup or bowl
Wimpy's Baked Scrod $28 Atlantic cod, seasoned crumb, butternut squash, whipped potato
Fish & Chips $26 Atlantic white fish, fries, coleslaw, house tartar
Lobster Roll $39 Warm roll, lettuce, celery, chives, lemon zest, mayo, fries
Homemade Chicken Pie $24 White meat chicken, house gravy, cranberry sauce, two sides
12oz Prime Rib $38 Au jus, two sides, available after 4 p.m.
Fresh Local Oysters $21 for six / $35 for twelve Mignonette, cocktail sauce, lemon

The baked scrod is the one dish with Wimpy's printed in its name. The chowder was the dish the Cape Cod Times chose to sum up the move, writing that guests would be able to eat Wimpy's chowder at the Roadhouse. The rest of the menu is a full Roadhouse dinner list, from Pecan Cod at $29 to Lobster Ravioli at $36 and Pan Seared Scallops at $37.

The Clock at 488 South Street Starts at 4 p.m.

The Roadhouse lists dinner daily from 4 p.m. to close. Lunch is marked "coming soon," and the site points guests to the Roadhouse Instagram for the announcement. Reservations go through Resy.

The evening-only schedule fits how this building has worked lately. When the Roadhouse reopened in October 2024 after four years closed, it served dinner from 4 to 10 p.m. daily in a 180-seat room, according to the Cape Cod Times. The current site describes the room as warm wood, the glow of the fireplace, and "intimate places to gather."

A House That Has Carried Several Names

The Roadhouse name runs deep at this address, which helps explain why the new owners are adding Wimpy's to it. Dave Colombo told the Cape Cod Times that he opened the Roadhouse Cafe in 1981 with breakfast, lunch and dinner. "We had 26 seats and we opened at 6 a.m.," he recalled. He said the circa-1902 house had once been the home and office of the Kennedy family's physician, and had housed other businesses over the years.

The place also has a jazz history. Colombo's father, trumpeter Lou Colombo, often stopped in to jam with friends, including Dave McKenna on piano, Dick Johnson of the Artie Shaw Orchestra, bassist Marshall Wood and guitarist Gray Sargent. Colombo's sister, Lori Colombo, sang. "A seat by the bar was the best seat in the place because you could see the musicians interacting with each other," Dave Colombo said.

Ricardo Conrado and Marcello Mallegni bought the restaurant and property from Colombo in February 2024 and reopened it that Oct. 11. Conrado spoke about keeping the Colombo family's jazz legacy going. "A lot of people talk about all their weddings and anniversaries they celebrated at Roadhouse Cafe," he said. Colombo still owns Colombo's on Main Street, Black Cat Tavern and Black Cat Harbor Shack, all in Hyannis, according to the same report.

When Hostetter and Pryshlak bought the Roadhouse on Sept. 26, 2026, the Cape Cod Times mentioned its "famous piano bar" as part of the draw. The same two owners also run Fancy's Market in Osterville and The Break Hyannis, a restaurant and bar across from Hyannis Harbor. Fancy's keeps them in Osterville, and the Roadhouse and The Break give them two places in Hyannis.

Some of Osterville Went Up for Sale

Not everything from 752 Main St. moved to South Street. In late October, the Cape Cod Times reported that Hostetter was selling some of Wimpy's antique Hunt Country Furniture to the public. The solid wood tables are built with mortise and tenon joints. They were priced at $300 to $500, against $1,500 to $2,500 new from the New York maker, and chairs were $100.

The recipes moved to Hyannis, and some of the dining room furniture was offered to the public. The name will follow once the state approves the license transfer at 488 South St.

When a long-standing business leaves its Main Street spot, people who own homes nearby often start asking what it means for their street. If you live near Main Street in Osterville or off South Street in Hyannis and want to know how these changes connect to your home's value, Tori Harrison Properties tracks Barnstable's villages one block at a time. Let's connect. Get your instant home valuation.

Partner with An Expert You Can Trust

Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, I’m here to make your real estate journey seamless and successful. With years of experience in Cape Cod’s unique market and a client-first approach, let’s work together to achieve your goals.

Follow Tori on Instagram